디시인사이드 갤러리

갤러리 이슈박스, 최근방문 갤러리

갤러리 본문 영역

이거 번역해볼까

구청과장(116.39) 2013.08.06 19:21:19
조회 21 추천 0 댓글 0


  • Players
  • 24914 battles
  • 1,343 message_img.png
  • [PURPL] PURPL
  • Member since:
    05-01-2011

*
POPULAR

WN7 formula:
(1240-1040/(MIN(TIER,6))^0.164)*FRAGS
+DAMAGE*530/(184*e^(0.24*TIER)+130)
+SPOT*125*MIN(TIER, 3)/3
+MIN(DEF,2.2)*100
+((185/(0.17+e^((WINRATE-35)*-0.134)))-500)*0.45
-[(5 - MIN(TIER,5))*125] / [1 + e^( ( TIER - (GAMESPLAYED/220)^(3/TIER) )*1.5 )]

Would like to highlight that MIN() means the number capped at that value, so MIN(TIER, 5) means avg tier capped at 5, (so player avg tier is used if it is lower than 5, otherwise 5 is used) and MIN(DEF,2.2) means defense is capped at 2.2.


WN7 SUMMARY 
written by Neverwish, Crabeatoff and Praetor77
Work on WN7 is a community effort. I consider everyone who has posted in this forum to have contributed their two cents into making WN what it is today. However, I would like to highlight the contribution of the people who have dedicated the most time and effort into making WN: 
Key contributors: Tpapp157, Neatoman, Syndicate, Maokai, Makaze2048, Guerdon, DracoArgentum, Crabeatoff, TheKilltech,  etc. etc.

The WN rating was created using statistical analysis tools like correlation studies and evolutionary algorythms to create an accurate formula, using Win Rate as a proxy to accurately determine the weight each stat would have in the formula. The idea was to create a formula which actually tried to measure player skill in the most accurate way possible, using global account stats.
The Efficiency formula was the basis for an analysis to figure out what was wrong with it and create an improved formula with those problems fixed.
WN is short for Weighed and Normalized, and implements various ways to deal with statpadding, and in the end tried to develop a metric that could only be padded by actually being good at the game.

Key points of the WN Rating are:
  • Damage is scaled according to your average tier and is the most important stat in the formula. The points you get for damage are carefully tied to the avg tier played, so that players with avg tier played 6 or 9 could be accurately compared, despite having very different average damage. To do this, average damage for tiers were collected from vbaddict.net and the data was carefully fitted to a non-linear curve.
  • Players with a considerable number of battles who have an average tier lower than 4 are heavily penalized for sealclubbing. New players with few battles under their belts are not penalized until they achieve a big number of battles but remain with a low average tier played.
  • Cap points are not counted towards your rating, since despite HUGE efforts and statistical analysis mainly performed by Syndicate, there was no statistically sound way to include cap points into the formula. The data suggests that for the average player cap points which are actually useful in winning a game for your team are drowned out by the huge amount of useless cap points gathered at the end of already won games.
  • Winrate is used as a proxy to measure intangible stats which are not available on the player profile like spotted damage, cap used to lure the enemy out, stopping scouts from killing your arty, tracking enemies at crucial moments, keeping your teammates alive, map awareness and other crucial decisions not recorded in the stats. This term of the forumla counts for 0-10% of final WN rating.
  • Average Defense points is capped at 2.2 to prevent padding. Defense also proved to be highly correlated to winrate, suggesting players who have map awareness and return to base when needed to stop enemy capping win more often.
  • One of the most important characteristics of the WN Rating is the open development format, meaning any player can post in this thread and suggest modifications, which will be tested and, if successful, implemented. By having this open development model, it effectively eliminates biases which closed formulas such as Efficiency have.
  • After the rating was released, WoTLabs was the first website to implement it, keeping it up to date every time a new version is launched. Although many people dislike the fast evolution of the rating (having gone through several changes and versions in only 4 months), this means that the formula rapidly grows more accurate. It has spread to the point where the WN Rating is now the standard rating used on the XVM mod, although transformed into a 0-99 scale rating.

Common Misconceptions
Despite having been based on advanced algorithms, the WN Rating did not pass without heavy criticism, although most, if not all, of this criticism turned out to be misconceptions.

One common complaint was that, if it was made to correlate with win rate, then we could just use win rate. Unfortunately win rate can be easily padded by platooning with good players. The WN Rating separates those padded players by using their actual stats. A veteran player with a low WN Rating but a high win rate has been probably been heavily padded.

Another common criticism is that we should stop caring about statistics and just play the game, since statistics eventually lead to mockery. Unfortunately World of Tanks is a competitive game, and as in all competitive games, there must be a measuring stick in order to know if you are improving and how much you are improving, otherwise we might as well go play Farmville. Shooting tanks for the heck of it gets boring after a while. The idea behind WN is to use it as a tool to make sure you keep improving, and also as a wealth of information when used in XVM to help you make critical decisions based on the skill of your teammates and enemies.

Other players criticize the formula for not taking things like spotting damage into account. This can hardly be pinned on the WN Rating, since Wargaming has not released this information publicly. The WN Rating can only work with what it has available. To account for those invisible stats that help win games, Win Rate has been added to the formula.

Lastly, many players criticized using winrate in the formula, since the very same winrate was used as a proxy to weigh the other stats in the evolutionary formula. However, as posted above, the idea was not to reward winrate, but to use it as a proxy for intangible stats. Also, the reward for these "intangibles" are carefully tailored by Neatoman into an S-curve with diminishing returns for winrates above 60%, where correlation to stats drop significantly, suggesting winrates above this value are purely due to platooning and companies. Also supporting this data is the fact that Zakaladas (quite possibly NA server´s best player) almost always plays solo and averages 64% wins.

Limitations and problems

Formulas can only be created from stats that are made available via the official WoT website. Efficiency depends on those same stats. Everything WoT-news computes is off those same stats. More information on YOUR history is available from the cached dossier file, but unless everyone starts mass uploading those (which will never happen), then the official website stats are THE source for data.
What isn't in WoT website stats?
  • Normalized Experience (XP) - theoretically WG could keep track of experience based on whether a user had a premium account or not, and then either remove the premium bonus OR give all standard account users the bonus (for stats purposes) to normalize XP across users.
  • Damage Upon Detection - Damage done to targets you are spotting yourself, by tanks who are not spotting them themselves. The latter is the bread and butter of light tanks (LTs) and of front line fighters. The other bonuses are relatively small compared to the latter. But it is the most noticeably missing in all rating calculations, and it particularly screws over LTs.
  • Per tank anything - the website cannot tell you damage per tank, spots per tank, etc. This information lives in your dossier and somewhere on the WG servers. If you use a dossier parsing tool (there are several web based and one local), you can obtain this information on your per tank performances. There is something called an API which gives you this kind of information, but currently the NA server API does not work correctly, like for example it says I have 15.4 spots per game on my IS-4.

Implications of these limitations

Light tanks
Due to the lack of DUD (damage upon spotting) on the WG website, light tanks are unfairly measured by WN7. They normally get lower WN7 scores than heavy, med or TDs of the same tier. That being said, WN7 is actually the metric that gives one of NA server´s best scouts (Redparadize) the highest rating...
PR: 1842
Eff2.0: 1742
WN7: 1943

SPGs
SPGs also cause issues, as their tiers are not lined up with the rest of tanks! They do much more damage than their tier value would indicate for a HT, MT or TD. This is a known limitation of the formulas. Extensive programming (parsing the website stats for SPG counts and adjusting their tier) COULD fix this, but the problem will go away when the SPGs tiers are stretched to match (per the latest ASAP with SerB). For now...we deal with it. Who care about SPG players stats anyways, amirite?!?!?

Some statistical limitations
When measuring a population, its not going to be possible to put every single person on the scale and have the scale make sense. Again, returning to a notable outlier, Tazilon and his 20k+ VK2801 games. This massive number of games means his average tier played is 5.35, which is lower than is "generally expected" for someone with 28k total games. It takes longer to move through higher tier tanks, and so you end up with more weight at 6+. Because WN7 is designed to measure the population relative to each other, some assumptions have to be made about the habits of the general population. Most players don't play 20k games in any single class or tier below 8, let alone 20k in a single tier 5. If someone plays 10k games in the MS-1....outlier! Takeaway: population ratings cannot account for every outlier.


Back to the formula
A detailed explanation of each portion of the WN7 formula by Crabeatoff and Praetor77.
Includes the answer to questions like "Why is cap not included in the formula?", "How much does winrate contribute to the equation" and "How does the low tier penalty work?":
Spoiler <input type="button" class="bbc_spoiler_show" value="Show " style="margin: 0px; padding: 0px; font-size: 10px; color: rgb(0, 0, 0);"><div class="bbc_spoiler_wrapper" style="margin: 0px; padding: 4px; border: 1px solid rgb(119, 119, 119);">

WN7 Scale
This is the current scale for the WN7 Rating:
WN7 Rating Key
Under 500 Very Bad
500 to 699 Bad
700 to 899 Below Average
900 to 1099 Average
1100 to 1349 Good
1350 to 1499 Very Good
1500 to 1699 Great
1700 to 1999 Unicum
2000 and Above Super Unicum

This scale is different from the one used in XVM, since their analysis of russian player database gave different results. The scale is currently on schedule to be readjusted to an analysis of the wotlabs player database being performed by Neverwish.

And this is what goes on inside the WN Rating. I hope I could clear some doubts regarding this formula! Feel free to post on this thread if you have any suggestions or questions.


EXTRAS

Boom_Box's script which modifies Player profile page and shows a lot of extra information, including WN7.

Excel sheet by Folterknecht for offline WN7 calculations

Wotlabs website for awesome signatures and other stats

Mywotstats website for signatures, player stats, and some neat features like customized server rankings for 30 or 60 day stats

Noobmeter website for noobmeter metric, WN7 stats, a neat history of your wN7, NM and WR stats, etc.

Old information for previous versions of WN:

포럼에 있는글


추천 비추천

0

고정닉 0

0

댓글 영역

전체 댓글 0
등록순정렬 기준선택
본문 보기

하단 갤러리 리스트 영역

왼쪽 컨텐츠 영역

갤러리 리스트 영역

갤러리 리스트
번호 제목 글쓴이 작성일 조회 추천
설문 연예인 안됐으면 어쩔 뻔, 누가 봐도 천상 연예인은? 운영자 24/06/17 - -
AD 뉴진스, 배틀그라운드로 데뷔 준비 완료! 운영자 24/06/21 - -
AD 현물 경품 획득 기회! 아키에이지 지역 점령전 업데이트 운영자 24/06/20 - -
440490 병오랑 대치하고있을때 병오 멘붕주는 법. [5] 별드라갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 120 2
440489 속도가 통곡 뺨치는데 선회는 88뺨침 [4] ww=ㄹㄹ갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 52 0
440488 왓더퍽 좆목 관련 알려드립니다 [9] 청운명갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 180 1
440487 B1., ..행복하다.... 구인갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 18 0
440486 병오 그 밥통에 타는 사람 거의 매판 죽냐? [4] ㅇㅇㅇ(112.160) 13.08.05 94 0
440483 왓더뻑 카톡 저거 내용 하나 빼고는 헛소리 ㅁㅅㅎㄹ(223.62) 13.08.05 48 0
440481 이 개같은 탱크 니들은 절대 스톡 타지말것을 권장한다 [1] ww=ㄹㄹ갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 65 0
440479 로레기 엔진업 어떰? [1] 나타드코코갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 31 0
440478 육감 소리점 높이려면 뭐 건드려야 해요? [2] 육감(112.160) 13.08.05 49 0
440477 떼44는 튼튼한 경전인듯함 [2] Foodnana갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 51 0
440476 마공스시에게 진실을요구함니다 [13] 레이먼드갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 390 0
440472 win7 어디까지 보고 오셧어요? [1] d(112.160) 13.08.05 49 2
440471 개념글 왓다빡의실체 저거 카톡조작어플로 조작한거같다 LadyLex갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 46 0
440469 병오툰구함 숙삼장인리숙면갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 15 0
440468 카톡으로 떠들든 말든.. [4] 마공스시갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 126 0
440467 월탱에서 탱크하나찾아요~~ [11] ㄹㄹㄹ(223.33) 13.08.05 92 0
440466 시골에 할머니들 쥐새끼 보면 밟아서 터트려 죽임 [4] ㅇㅇ(119.198) 13.08.05 79 0
440464 보드게임 머리아프게 하고와따 홍차의 망령(116.41) 13.08.05 16 0
440463 레나가 진심 이렇게 생김? [2] Astime(211.213) 13.08.05 119 0
440462 때사사 승률 60달성 ^오^ [1] ㅁㅇㅇㄹ(211.197) 13.08.05 44 0
440461 아니 개 씨부랄 포신은 적 방향 모르나 씨부랄새끼들 [1] ww=ㄹㄹ갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 49 0
440459 희망과 진실 [4] 부라퀴(218.148) 13.08.05 87 1
440458 경전에 위장막 비효율적임 [6] LadyLex갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 99 0
440457 개념글 왓다빡의 실체 뭐냐? [5] 마공스시갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 132 0
440455 간첩 찾았읍니다 -- [2] 엑읔(58.234) 13.08.05 52 0
440454 이거 소비자 보호센터 인가에 신고가능하냐? [4] 오곡만비(219.240) 13.08.05 74 0
440452 스톡병사 오늘도 별떼다 4연패째다. 질문받는다 [2] ww=ㄹㄹ갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 33 1
440451 요즘도 자주지킨다고 베이스저격하는 중전차가 있네 [1] ㅇㅇ(119.198) 13.08.05 40 0
440450 지금 t29,t32,m103 꿀잼으로 탔는데 e5도 꿀잼이냐? [3] ㅂㅈㄷ(112.163) 13.08.05 75 0
440449 리센트 왜이럼 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ;; Octavarium.갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 44 0
440447 야 T71 이퀍 추천좀 [4] ..(180.224) 13.08.05 62 0
440446 월오탱 여신3탑.jpg [4] 오나오너(119.194) 13.08.05 129 0
440445 으씹알 장마 끝난거 아닌가요? 그르르(203.226) 13.08.05 15 0
440444 개인적으로 네코 白에서는 [3] 피오 오덕후갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 81 0
440443 3일 채금 처분을 3일 정지로 쳐주네 워게이 병신들ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ [7] 오곡만비(219.240) 13.08.05 769 2
440442 4202의 마지막 미스테리 구인갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 47 0
440441 강윤이님 제송합니다... [1] 훼더갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 38 0
440440 카나번 28프로토 판투 중에 뭐 먼저 뚫는게 나음? [2] asd(182.210) 13.08.05 21 0
440437 4202는 해쉬탄 평관 씹상향 해주고 dpm 4000은 줘야할듯 [1] ㅁㄱㅌㅊ(39.116) 13.08.05 38 0
440436 월탱에 나중에 3세대전차까지 나옴 ㅇㅇ? 피오 오덕후갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 9 0
440434 FV4202전면 50밀 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ [2] LadyLex갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 105 0
440431 FV 4202 레오갓처럼 됬다고합니다.... 수류탄이여갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 60 0
440429 영자주 탈만하냐?? 늅에는늅이에는이갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 10 0
440428 홍차 구리다는거 다 거짓말임 ㅇㅇ(119.198) 13.08.05 20 1
440427 궁금한게있는데 조우전 끄는 이유는 뭐임?? [5] 국방부노예갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 113 0
440426 와 어떻게 저렇게 얇을수가 있냐 ㅁㄴㅇ(175.193) 13.08.05 18 0
440424 E25탈때 가장 빡치는 탱이 뭐냐? [5] ☎2.52™갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 120 0
440423 FV4202의 운명은 어떻게 될것인가? [1] 부라퀴(218.148) 13.08.05 120 0
440421 홍차국 전차들 사실 다 장갑 속인거 아닐까? 구인갤로그로 이동합니다. 13.08.05 26 0
440420 오비약트 704 에이스 딴놈 있냐? [3] 발전맨(175.201) 13.08.05 72 0
갤러리 내부 검색
제목+내용게시물 정렬 옵션

오른쪽 컨텐츠 영역

실시간 베스트

1/8

뉴스

디시미디어

디시이슈

1/2